Clarification about certifying product vs management practices
Friday, May 23rd, 2008The international Organisation that sets standards is ISO. They have set up the ISO 14,000 series of standards to cover environmental certification and this includes two major areas;
• ISO 14,001 certifies environmental practices and behaviour in a business
• ISO 14,020 series covers environmental products.
The ISO 14001 certifications are audited by trained auditors working for a variety of certification bodies with built in and transparent checks and balances.
The Product certification is administered by a series of not for profit organisations that help businesses get their products certified “following the guidelines” of ISO 14020. In Australia this is administered by Good Environmental Choice.
My question for both certifications is about the quality of the auditing process. I know that a few high profile ISO 14001 businesses that still have breaches of the law yet retain their certification cause scepticism of the benefits of ISO 14001 by some of the green groups. This is clearly an auditor problem and we had some fairly robust discussion about this at the recent Environmental management Systems Forum I attended in Newcastle NSW this week. Click here to access my paper and my PowerPoint slides on “greenwash” which was updated before delivery to reflect some of the discussion. Even in those businesses that still cause occasional breaches, my experience has been that the ISO 14001 implementation and certification process has caused a real cultural change in the business and much improved environmental practices.
The auditing process for the product certification is much less transparent and much more confusing for the public. I also have concerns about what is meant by “following the guidelines”.
It is my firm opinion that certifying management practices to ISO 14001 is the best way to go. If an ISO 14001 certified business also sells ISO 140020 certified products – they you have a good choice and there should be more overlap.
The ISO 14001 standard is very clear, the auditor’s job is to check what you say is compliant with the standard and also that you DO what you SAY. Where a business has a policy that states it obeys all legislative requirements and still has regular legal breaches, the auditor is failing in his job if he does not require corrective action to avoid loss of certification. This needs to be remedied by the auditing bodies and addressed by the ACCC (Australian Company and Consumer Commission) when investigating “green” claims.
I have much more concern about the plethora of product standards, what they mean and how they fit into the carbon cycle and the carbon auditing we are all embarking on from July 1 in Australia.
Technorati Tags: Clarification about certifying product vs management practices, product vs management practices, ISO 14001